Navigation

    Voting Theory Forum

    • Register
    • Login
    • Search
    • Recent
    • Categories
    • Tags
    • Popular
    • Users
    • Groups
    1. Home
    2. Popular
    Log in to post
    • All categories
    • All Topics
    • New Topics
    • Watched Topics
    • Unreplied Topics
    • All Time
    • Day
    • Week
    • Month
    • GregW

      Consensus Choice, a new (2024) and simple Condorcet voting method
      Single-winner • • GregW

      10
      1
      Votes
      10
      Posts
      60
      Views

      C

      @poppeacock a “Condorcet winner” is a candidate that beats every other candidate in a majoritarian head-to-head match up, also called a “beats all” winner. There can be at most one Condorcet winner in an election; however, there are pathological cases when a Condorcet winner does not exist at all, caused by what are known as Condorcet cycles.

      The classic example is three voters using rank ballots over three candidates:

      V1: A>B>C
      V2: B>C>A
      V3: C>A>B

      You can see that A>B 2:1, B>C 2:1, but C>A 2:1. So A>B>C>A is a Condorcet cycle, which is a generalized “rock-paper-scissors” situation. Whichever candidate you choose as the winner, there is some majority of the voters who would have preferred a different candidate. That’s the unfortunate thing that happens when a Condorcet winner doesn’t exist…

      Regardless, a Condorcet method is any method that guarantees electing the Condorcet winner when one exists. Condorcet methods differ in how they reconcile choosing a winner when the Condorcet winner does not exist, I.e. in effect how they determine which majority group(s) to jilt.

      So for example, if Ranked Robin doesn’t specify how it resolves when there is no Condorcet winner, then it’s really a blanket term for Condorcet methods in general. Or maybe it’s a label for a particular curated subset of Condorcet methods.

    • C

      Smith Primary to Approval
      Advocacy • • cfrank

      9
      0
      Votes
      9
      Posts
      54
      Views

      J

      @cfrank I'm still talking about a single-winner system. The winner would be chosen in the general election.